The Giver

by Lois Lowry

---

Chapter 20

---

Summary

Chapter 20 of The Giver opens in the aftermath of Jonas’s devastating discovery. He has just watched the video of his father “releasing” the smaller of the twin newchildren — watched him inject the lethal substance into the infant’s forehead and dispose of the body down a chute. Jonas is shattered. He refuses to go home. He tells The Giver flatly that he will not go back to his family unit, will not return to the dwelling where his father lives and sleeps and speaks in the gentle, cheerful voice that Jonas now understands conceals an unconscious capacity for killing. The Giver lets Jonas stay the night in his quarters, understanding that the boy has crossed a threshold from which there is no return.

Jonas’s grief is not only for the dead infant. It is for the entire structure of his life. Everything he believed about the community — its safety, its kindness, its protection of its members — has been exposed as a system built on elimination. Release is not a peaceful departure to Elsewhere. It is death, administered routinely and without remorse by people who do not understand what they are doing. Jonas’s father did not murder the newchild with malice. He murdered it with pleasantness, and that is worse. Jonas now sees his community with total clarity: it is a place where people kill without knowing they kill, where language has been so thoroughly sanitized that the act of ending a life carries no more emotional weight than filing paperwork. Jonas cannot unknow this. He cannot return to the family unit and sit through the evening sharing of feelings with a man who casually destroys infants as part of his professional duties.

The Giver, who has carried this knowledge alone for years, recognizes that Jonas has arrived at the same unbearable understanding. Rather than offering comfort, The Giver redirects Jonas’s anguish toward action. The two of them begin to formulate a plan. The Giver explains what happened when Rosemary — the previous Receiver-in-training — was released ten years earlier. When Rosemary died, the memories she had received returned to the community. They flooded back into the general population, and the people were overwhelmed. They had no framework for grief, for pain, for loss. The Giver was the only one who could help them process what they were experiencing, and he did, guiding them through the chaos until the memories faded and order was restored.

This precedent becomes the foundation of their plan. If Jonas leaves the community, all the memories he has accumulated over months of training will be released back into the population — just as Rosemary’s were. But this time, the volume of memories will be far greater. Jonas has received a year’s worth of transmissions: memories of war, starvation, color, music, love, snow, sunburn, broken bones, elephants, birthday celebrations, grandparents, death. When these memories return to the people, the community will be thrown into emotional turmoil. They will experience feelings they have no words for, see colors they have been trained to ignore, feel pain they have been chemically shielded from. They will need help. And The Giver will be there to provide it.

The plan is specific. Jonas will leave the community during the night, before the upcoming December Ceremony. The Giver will arrange for Jonas to be hidden in the storage area of a delivery vehicle. Once outside the community’s boundaries, Jonas will make his way to Elsewhere — the world beyond the borders, whatever it may contain. Neither of them knows exactly what lies beyond. They know only that it is outside the community’s control, and that is enough.

Jonas asks The Giver to come with him. The request is urgent and sincere — Jonas cannot imagine facing the unknown alone, and he does not want to leave behind the only person who truly understands him. But The Giver refuses. He offers two reasons. First, he says he is too old and too weak to survive the journey. His body has been worn down by decades of carrying the community’s memories, and he does not trust himself to endure the physical demands of escape. Second, and more importantly, the community will need him. When the memories flood back, the people will be in crisis. Without The Giver to guide them, the chaos could be catastrophic. He must stay behind to serve the same function he served after Rosemary’s release, but on a much larger scale.

Then The Giver reveals something else — something quieter, more personal. He tells Jonas that after the community has been stabilized, after the people have begun to absorb the memories and find their footing, he wants to be with Rosemary. The implication is unmistakable. The Giver does not expect to survive long after Jonas leaves. He does not want to. Rosemary was his daughter — or at the very least, the person he loved most deeply — and her loss has defined his existence ever since. Once his final duty to the community is fulfilled, The Giver intends to join her. Whether this means requesting his own release or simply allowing himself to die, the result is the same. The Giver is planning his own end.

The chapter closes with the plan in place. Jonas and The Giver have mapped out the logistics of escape: the timing, the vehicle, the route. The December Ceremony provides cover, as the community will be distracted by the annual rituals of assignment and celebration. Jonas will disappear in the night, and by the time anyone notices his absence, the memories will already be returning. The Giver will remain behind, steady and solitary, doing what he has always done — absorbing the pain that others cannot bear, one last time.

Character Development

Jonas completes his transformation from obedient citizen to conscious rebel. His refusal to return home is not a tantrum or a temporary reaction — it is a permanent severance. He has seen what his community truly is, and he cannot participate in it any longer. His willingness to flee into the unknown, alone, demonstrates a courage that has been building since his first training session. He is no longer the boy who felt apprehensive at the Ceremony of Twelve. He is someone prepared to risk death for the possibility of a life that is real. The Giver, in turn, reveals the full scope of his character. His refusal to leave is not cowardice but responsibility. He understands that the community he has served — the community that has caused him decades of suffering — will need him one final time, and he will not abandon them. His desire to “be with Rosemary” adds a dimension of grief that has been present but unspoken throughout the novel. The Giver is not merely tired. He is bereaved, and he has been bereaved for ten years, carrying that loss alongside every other memory in his custody.

Themes and Motifs

The theme of sacrifice reaches its culmination. Both Jonas and The Giver are giving up everything — Jonas his family, his safety, and his known world; The Giver his remaining years and any chance of personal freedom. Their sacrifices are complementary: Jonas will carry the memories outward, releasing them back to the community, while The Giver will remain to manage the consequences. The motif of Elsewhere undergoes its final transformation. Throughout the novel, “Elsewhere” has been a euphemism for death — a comfortable fiction the community uses to avoid confronting what release actually means. Now, for Jonas, Elsewhere becomes a literal destination, a place of unknown possibility. The irony is deliberate: Jonas is fleeing toward the word the community uses to describe death, and in doing so, he is choosing life. The theme of knowledge as burden also reaches its resolution. Jonas and The Giver have both been crushed by what they know. Their plan is an attempt to redistribute that burden — to force the community to share in the knowledge that has been confined to two people.

Notable Passages

“I want to be with Rosemary.”

The Giver’s quiet declaration carries the weight of the entire novel. It is at once an expression of love, a confession of exhaustion, and an acceptance of death. The Giver does not dramatize this statement. He does not explain it at length. He simply says it, and the simplicity is what makes it devastating. He has spent a decade carrying memories of every human joy and agony, and the only future he desires is reunion with the person he lost. For students, this line reveals that The Giver’s stoicism has always been a form of endurance, not indifference. He has been waiting — waiting for someone like Jonas to come along, so that he could finish his work and finally rest.

“If you get away, if you get beyond, if you get to Elsewhere, it will mean that the community has to bear the burden themselves, of the memories you had been holding for them.”

This passage crystallizes the logic of the escape plan and, by extension, the novel’s central argument. The community has outsourced its emotional and moral life to a single individual. Jonas’s departure will force every citizen to become, for the first time, a full human being — one who feels pain and joy, who sees color, who carries the weight of history. The Giver frames this as a burden, but it is also a gift. The community will suffer, but it will also, for the first time, be alive.

Analysis

Chapter 20 functions as the novel’s strategic pivot. The preceding chapters built Jonas’s awareness — of color, of pain, of love, and finally of death. This chapter converts awareness into action. Lowry structures the planning scene with deliberate precision, giving the escape enough logistical detail to feel plausible while withholding enough to maintain suspense. The Giver’s refusal to accompany Jonas is the chapter’s most structurally important decision. It ensures that Jonas will face the final act of the novel alone, stripped of his mentor, forced to rely entirely on himself and the memories he carries. It also ensures that The Giver’s story ends in sacrifice rather than escape, giving his character an arc that is complete and tragic. The chapter’s emotional power derives from the contrast between the enormity of the plan and the quietness of the conversation. Two people sit in a room and decide to dismantle the only social order either has ever known. There is no dramatic confrontation, no public declaration of rebellion. There is only a boy who refuses to go home and an old man who wants to see his daughter again. Lowry trusts the reader to understand that these small, private decisions are the most consequential acts in the novel. Students should recognize that this chapter sets up the novel’s remaining tension: not whether Jonas will escape, but what will happen when he does — both to him and to the community he leaves behind.